Extended effects or separability doctrine?

Two virtually simultaneous decisions, issued by two different lower Courts, reached opposite conclusions (Court of Catania, decision No. 1020 of 13 March 2020, Italian text available here; and Court of Milan, decision No. 2091 of 11 March 2020, Italian text available here).  The legal grounds of both these decisions are indicated under Article 118, para. 1, of the Implementing Provisions of Italian Code of Civil Procedure.  In other words, they merely refer to judicial precedents.

In its decision of 11 March 2020, the Court of Milan held that an arbitration clause contained in a company’s articles of association may be enforced towards a former shareholder, provided that the relevant dispute refers to the corporate relationship, regardless of when it has been brought.

In its decision of 13 March 2020, the Court of Catania reached the opposite conclusion: the arbitration clause cannot be enforced towards a former shareholder.

The case heard by the Court of Milan concerned the member’s obligation to contribute to a consortium company, while the case heard by the Court of Catania concerned the repayment of a shareholder loan, but the opposite outcomes of the decisions do not arise of these details.

The Court of Catania refers to the authority of Italian Supreme Court, VI Civil Chamber, decision No. 21036 of 11 September 2017.  In that case, the Supreme Court held that the arbitration clause contained in the articles of association of the company, which in the meantime had transformed into a limited liability company, was not enforceable against the member who had withdrawn from the company, when it was a general partnership.  The reason is clear: given that the withdrawal immediately produces its effects, the former member “is (…) no longer part of the corporate relationship that continues in the different form resulting from the transformation.  Therefore, the clauses of the articles of association, governing the company in its new form, cannot be enforced against her”.

The case heard by the Court of Catania was completely different.  As far as it can be understood in the light of the content of the decision, the arbitration clause was included in the articles of association also before the shareholder dismissed her shares.

As a consequence, the mere reference to the said judicial precedent amounts to a proper lack of grounds of decision: not only in the light of the fact that the precedent referred to a different situation, but because it is precisely based on the peculiarities of that different situation.

The decision of the Court of Milan appears more grounded, in that it is more appropriate in relation to the specific case the Court heard.

The Court of Milan first of all refers to the authority of another decision issued by Italian Supreme Court: Italian Supreme Court, I Civil Chamber, decision No. 565 of 22 January 1999.  That decision concerned a quite different case, concerning a contractual dispute.  However, a principle laid down by the Supreme Court is also relevant in the case heard by the Court of Milan: “all disputes concerning the contract are referred to arbitration, under the relevant clause, including the disputes concerning the contract very existence, its validity, termination, and fulfilment, even if they arise after the termination of the contractual relationship between the parties, as long as they concern the contractual relationship”.

Previous decisions issued by the same Court of Milan (issued on 15 July 2017 and 23 January 2017) upheld this principle, laid down with respect to contractual disputes, taking account of the peculiarities of corporate disputes.

Both these decisions underline a crucial aspect: also in corporate matters, “arbitral agreements (…) concerning certain disputes have to be construed in accordance with separability doctrine, so that they will survive the termination of the relevant contract (…) and are not affected by the unenforceability of (other) contractual provisions”(2014 decision) . In other words, “the issue of enforceability of the clause (…) has to be addressed in the light of separability doctrine, which is now expressly provided for by the law in force” (2017 decision).

Separability doctrine means that the arbitration clause is enforceable even though the relevant contract is unenforceable or terminated.  There is no reason, on a logical or legal basis, why the separability doctrine should not apply to arbitration clauses contained in companies’ articles of association.  As a consequence, in the event of termination of the said articles – complete termination (as in the case heard by the Court of Milan in 2017) or limited to a sole shareholder (as in the other cases) – the arbitration clause is enforceable.  This is not a consequence of the clause having extended effects, but a correct application of separability doctrine.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Browsing this website you accept the use of cookies. more info

The following information is provided in accordance with Article 13 of Regulation (EU) 679/2018 ("GDPR"), to users who access the services available at https://www.arbitratoinitalia.it (“Site”). When consulting the Site, information concerning users may be collected that constitutes personal data under the Privacy Code. This information is provided exclusively for the Site and does not affect any other web sites accessible by the user through links provided on the same.
Data Controller (Titolare del trattamento) is Arbitration in Italy Ltd, a company incorporated under English law, registered at No. 12459814, with registered office in 61 Bridge Street, Kington, HR5 3DJ, UK ("Company"). Data Processor (Responsabile del trattamento) is the Company's present legal representative.
The processing of data related to the web services on this Site is carried out at the premises of the Company set out above and is performed by internal personnel duly appointed as Persons in charge of processing (Incaricati del trattamento).
Surfing Data
During the normal operation, the computer systems and software procedures used to operate the Site acquire some personal data whose transmission is implicit in the communication protocols of the Internet. This information is not collected to be associated with identified persons, but by its very nature could, through processing and association with data held by third parties, allow identification of users. This category of data includes IP addresses or domain names of computers used by users who connect to the Site, URI (Uniform Resource Identifier) of requested resources, the time of the request, the method used to submit the request to the server, the size of the file obtained in reply, the numerical code indicating the status of the response from the server (successful, error, etc.) and other parameters regarding the operating system and computer environment. These data are used only to obtain statistical information about the site and its use and to check its correct functioning and are deleted immediately after processing. The data could be used to ascertain responsibility in the event of possible computer crimes committed against the Site: except in this case, the data on web contacts are kept for a maximum period of seven days.
Data provided voluntarily by the user
The sending of optional, explicit and voluntary e-mails to addresses shown on this Site, and the filling in of forms specifically provided involve the subsequent acquisition of the sender’s e-mail address and the additional personal data provided in the electronic communication, together with the sender/user’s data necessary to respond to requests as well as to provide the service. Specific summary information will be provided in relation to specific services.
Cookies are data files which some websites, while visited, can send to the user with the scope of tracing its path inside the site and collect data in anonymous form, in order to enhance the offer and the use of the site. The Company does not use information technology for the direct acquisition of personal data by which the user can be identified. Cookies for the transmission of personal information or systems for the tracing of users are not used. The Company uses so-called technical cookies only with the scope of rendering browsing the Site possible and to make it possible for the user to use its functions. Some technical cookies are necessary in order to optimize the use and have the user accredit itself with the Site, for example in order to enter a restricted area (so-called browser cookie). The browsing cookies are session cookies and are deactivated automatically once the browser is closed. For the installation of these cookies it is not necessary to collect the consent of the user. The Company uses furthermore analytic cookies of thirds parties by which information on the interaction of the visitor with the content of the Site is obtained (most frequently used pages, time of use, etc.) and which thereby provide statistic information which makes it possible to optimize the Site and to enhance its use.
Unless specified for surfing data, the user is free to provide personal information in the application forms or otherwise indicate them in order to request any information packs or other communications. Failure to provide personal information may, however, make it impossible to fulfill the request.
Personal data are processed by automated tools for the time necessary to achieve the purposes for which they were collected. Specific security measures have been taken to prevent loss of data, unlawful or incorrect use and unauthorized access.
The personal information provided by users who request dispatch of information packs or rendering of services is used only to provide the service requested and may be disclosed to Company’s employees and consultants, duly appointed as Persons in charge of processing, as well as third parties that render ancillary or instrumental services to the activity of the Company and which are appointed as Data Controllers. There will not be any other communication of data to third parties, except upon request of public authorities. The data collected will not be disseminated.
Data subjects are entitled, pursuant to Article 12 of the GDPR, to obtain, at any time, confirmation of the existence of the data and to know their origin, verify their accuracy or request their integration, updating or correction. Pursuant to this article data subjects shall have the right to request cancellation, anonymization or blocking of data processed in violation of the law, and in any case, to object on legitimate grounds to their processing. Requests should be sent to the Data Processor, at the above address or by email to privacy@arbitratoinitalia.it.